“Vodka is not about what you put in but what you take out before the final product,” Abou-Ganim said. The drink's production process remains largely a proprietary secret, but the difference may not matter as much given federal regulations. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here. However, I am very interested in whether or not they are bottled in the same factory/area. These questions are central to a viral claim that’s circulated online for years. Kirkland Signature French Vodka is comparable to Grey Goose (and often preferred over it). Topping the list, however, was Kirkland's French (red label) vodka, perhaps one of Costco's all-time best buys.While it is not actually repackaged Grey Goose, it is sourced from the same waters — the Gensac Springs in France's Cognac region (via Vice). “It costs more to produce a vodka with rye or wheat than with sugarcane, for instance. French Vodka. Grey goose uses grain neutral spirits in theirs - it's actually a low quality vodka that prices itself very high to appearp "premium". A post went up on Reddit comparing two well-known vodkas through UnderTheLabel, a Consumers Digest -like site that offers intriguing facts about alcohol and spirits. (July 16), an article from the recipe site 12Tomatoes read, That certificate states the brand is produced by the LeVecke Corp. in Mira Loma, California, Bacardi to buy Patrón tequila in $5.1B premium spirits deal, The certificates issued for Grey Goose’s various American products, though a 2016 VICE report found that Kirkland Signature’s French Vodka also taps a well in the Gensac Springs region, Kirkland Signature French Vodka states on its bottle that it is distilled five times, 4 foods and drinks to avoid before going to sleep, and has regularly topped Grey Goose in blind taste tests, mandated that vodka must be distilled and treated, Fact check: It's true, U.S. government poisoned some alcohol during Prohibition, which is why the TTB recently redefined vodka, Joe McCanta, Grey Goose Global Head of Education, Interview with Tony Abou-Ganim, "The Modern Mixologist", VICE, Why Costco’s Vodka May Be Your Best Bet, Buzzfeed on YouTube, Costco Liquor Vs. I'm not 100 % sure if my answer helps but Kirkland vodka is up there with kettle one and grey goose. Regulations Change. just filter it though an activated carbon filter a few times. What makes a good vodka anyway? “If all vodkas were the same we’d only have one vodka. Are they referring to the American (blue) bottle for $12.99 or the red bottle … The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, which regulates the sale and importation of alcohol, has approved only one Certificate of Label Approval for Kirkland Signature vodka. ... there are lots of rumors that Kirkland and Grey Goose are made at the same plant. Does anyone actually have firsthand knowledge on the subject? Kirkland Signature French Vodka is a popular drink among Costco shoppers, and has regularly topped Grey Goose in blind taste tests. ", More: Fact check: It's true, U.S. government poisoned some alcohol during Prohibition, Some argued the regulation flattened the range of tastes that vodkas available in the U.S. could have, which is why the TTB recently redefined vodka as any “neutral spirits” that can include “up to 2 grams per liter of sugar and up to 1 gram per liter of citric acid.”. Grey Goose, which is owned by Bacardi, has, naturally, denied that it also produces the Kirkland variety. Now I'm not asking whether they are the same product (clearly that's illegal). Grey Goose / Costco ... Kirkland Signature Vodka has trounced the expensive name brand in multiple blind taste tests despite being a fraction of the price. They are made with the same quality ingredients in the same region in France. Grey Goose has unequivocally denied making Kirkland brand vodka, but they do have something in common. I only buy it when I am spoiling myself. While differences in the prices of wheat, water and the machinery used for distillation may be individually small among products, those initial costs can compound to produce wide variations in price. 2 and 3) don't know. Vodka enthusiasts contend that high quality ingredients and a more stringent process, like the one used by Grey Goose, justify its high price tag, Abou-Ganim explained. “No, Grey Goose Vodka does not produce nor privately label Kirkland vodka,” Joe McCanta, Grey Goose’s Global Head of Education, told USA TODAY. Other factors, including the production and origin of the vodkas, mean that while the two products may taste similar for some, they are different drinks. This Vodka is a step up, at least in price, from the Kirkland Signature Premium Domestic Vodka USA 1.75L.It comes in a nicer looking bottle and is a product of France. I find it mixes well with everything, and seen a show one time where people who said they were picky and only drank Grey goose or Kettle one ,couldn't tell the difference in a blind taste taste. I have witnessed so many discussions/arguments about whether Kirkland Vodka is the same as Grey Goose. Now I'm not asking whether they are the same product (clearly that's illegal). “This is a viral claim that has circled Grey Goose for many years and it’s completely false.”. For the chocolate lovers of the world, Costco's All American … Finlandia routinely wins over grey goose in vodka tastings. It is only the French vodka that is really comparable to Grey Goose, and what's more, Grey Goose categorically denies the rumors, as does the Bacardi brand that owns Grey Goose, according to Thrillist . If u have questions, ask me, winery in my family. 4) I start my evening with vodka and Coke Zero. It's okay to admit to drinking cheap liquor. Wine. Price: $14.99. “No, Grey Goose Vodka does not produce nor privately label Kirkland vodka,” Joe McCanta, Grey Goose’s Global Head of Education, told USA TODAY. The two have been through several blind taste tests and Kirkland Signature usually wins — plus, depending on your location, it may be half the price of the name brand stuff (or even less). Brand-Name Liquor Blind Taste Test, Cornell Legal Institute, Labeling and Advertising of Distilled Spirits, Food & Wine, Vodka Can Finally Have a ‘Distinctive Character’ Thanks to U.S. The question breathed life back into a years-old belief among many that the big box store's less expensive and reportedly high-quality vodka was actually the prestigious vodka brand in different packaging. Then add a few jolly ranchers of your desired flavor if you wish for a flavored vodka. Grey Goose told USA TODAY its vodka is distilled only once “in an effort to preserve the quality natural ingredients and profiles of its ingredients.” Kirkland Signature French Vodka states on its bottle that it is distilled five times. Despite these differences, the Kirkland-made-by-Grey Goose claims raise questions of how different luxury brands really are from their cheaper counterparts. L. LikeLinus Lifer. “And hopefully, in turn, for the additional expense that you put in, the consumer will have a better experience at the end,” Abou-Ganim said. It came up at a party two weekends ago when we were drinking Kirkland "craft brews." The certificates issued for Grey Goose’s various American products all state the products originate in France, confirming Grey Goose statements to USA TODAY. To address the first issue regarding the Grey Goose rumor, there are actually two types of Kirkland vodka: a cheaper American version and a pricier French version. Very high quality stuff. “Is Costco’s Kirkland Brand of Vodka The Same As Grey Goose?” an article from the recipe site 12Tomatoes reads. One of the most fun rumors to ever come out of Costco is that its generic Kirkland brand vodka is actually the same exact liquor that ends up in Grey Goose bottles. is kirkland vodka grey goose; Browse our posts that related to : is kirkland vodka grey goose - is costco vodka grey goose - is kirkland french vodka grey goose - is kirkland vodka gray goose - is kirkland vodka really grey goose - is kirkland vodka really gray goose - kirkland vodka grey goose reddit - Bellow. Grey Goose vodka. Kirkland Signature Original Spiced Rum. r/AskReddit is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions. Freeze (cheep vodka has freezable water in it), remove the water. This is just my own opinion. More: Bacardi to buy Patrón tequila in $5.1B premium spirits deal. “Really, the only way to learn more is to taste.”. Grey Goose vs Kirkland Vodka? Kirkland vodka is made by Grey Goose, its bourbon by Jim Beam and its scotch by Macallan 18. Kirland vodka is almost certainly made by one of the big name vodka distillers. While the brands may have some similar ingredients and distillation practices, these are not coordinated efforts. Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. ... Facebook Twitter Reddit Tumblr WhatsApp Email Link. Overall, though, they found it to be … I've heard this as well. Also, Kirkland Vodka is not re-bottled Grey Goose. The internet’s opinion: It doesn’t take much … There has long been a rumor that a Costco Kirkland-brand vodka imported from France is produced by the high-end brand Grey Goose. The source of your water could factor into the price, and then there’s importation costs,” he said. I plan on doing a blind tasting some day- maybe after I finish the Fris. The move recognizes that flavored vodkas and other styles of vodka popular elsewhere in the world exist and opens the possibility for more styles of vodka to be produced in the United States. most Kirlkand products are actually produced by the makers of "name brand" items and then labelled differently. Grey Goose This is the spirit that everyone thinks is secretly poured into bottles of Kirkland, but it was clear right away that this is a very different product. Wine also has to breathe. Also, VODKA MUST BE CHILLED. All current evidence indicates that Kirkland Signature French Vodka, nor any other products sold by Costco, are in any way affiliated with the Grey Goose brand. However, it doesn't matter much whether Grey Goose makes Kirkland's Signature vodka — it turns out that Costco's store brand may actually be better. Does anyone know more about this. It is comparable to Grey Goose in quality. For years, the Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms Code mandated that vodka must be distilled and treated until it is "without distinctive character, aroma, taste or color. More: 4 foods and drinks to avoid before going to sleep. Claims that comparable products are being sold under brands with wildly different price tags is nothing new. Experts: Men should limit alcohol to 1 drink a day, If you decide to have an alcoholic drink, limiting yourself to one a day is best — whether you're a man or woman. Costco does not disclose its ingredients' origins, though a 2016 VICE report found that Kirkland Signature’s French Vodka also taps a well in the Gensac Springs region. Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook. 31 votes, 31 comments. But Grey Goose expressly denies the claims are true, citing the unique qualities and process of its brand. Grey Goose argues its investments and exclusive access to ingredients gives its brand “a richer, deeper taste profile,” according to McCanta. They were pretty damn good. IMO Grey Goose is x10 the vodka that most other English Labels are. That's the new advice experts are recommending for the updated U.S. Dietary Guidelines. As Vice describes, both liquors are made with water "from the Gensac Springs in France's Cognac region." I buy cheap vodka like Smirnoff and my favorite is Stoli. But being a poor college student I've discovered this trick: cheep vodka, run through a Brita filter about 3-5 times. Btw, LET YOUR VODKA BREATHE. We rate this claim FALSE. They told us it is not bottled by Grey Goose, but wouldn't say who actually bottles it for them. The differences are subtle,” Tony Abou-Ganim, a mixologist and the author of “Vodka Distilled,” told USA TODAY. “From harvest to milling to distillation to bottling, every step is done in France. Not much, unfortunately. Use a proper drinking glass with some rocks. subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here. Now there has been a long time rumor that this Vodka is actually just Grey Goose Vodka & that it is just bottled under the Kirkland brand. But drink what you like and can afford. Press J to jump to the feed. If this is true, does it mean that they are the same formula? I think grey goose does this by adding a tiny bit of undistilled grain or fermented mash into the final product - people with celiac disease have problems with some vodka brands for this reason. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. “It’s OK to like and use more than one type of vodka!”. yes, the vodka is in a very simular bottle, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I have witnessed so many discussions/arguments about whether Kirkland Vodka is the same as Grey Goose. “Everyone has some type of perspective on Grey Goose; it signifies something. I heard from a person who works at a winery that Grey Goose and Costco's Kirkland brand vodka are made at the same plant. Grey Goose is garbo, Ketel crushes them all. At its core, vodka is distilled alcohol and water, but the ingredients and process used to make the alcohol vary by brand and country. That doesn’t mean that Grey Goose isn’t high quality, but that “you have to go and do the work to decide what’s the right taste for you,” Abou-Ganim said. ASK THE COMMUNITY. 4. If you want add a very small splash of grenedine to it. Why would it be illegal to sell the same product under two different brands? Everyone raves about the Kirkland brand vodka. Only Grey Goose uses single origin Picardy wheat and water from our natural limestone well in Gensac-la-Pallue to craft a gluten free spirit of exceptional character,” McCanta told USA TODAY. However, in blind taste tests, Kirkland has actually outperformed Grey Goose. That certificate states the brand is produced by the LeVecke Corp. in Mira Loma, California. 99% of the time I buy Smirnoff though. Someone knew someone that worked for whomever makes Grey Goose, that person said the same stuff is bottled at Kirkland. Fee’s makes their bitters with it. Regardless, consumers can decide for themselves which is the better vodka. Costco's Kirkland Signature vodka has scored higher than Grey Goose in blind tastings. However, I am very interested in whether or not they are bottled in the same factory/area. Thank you for supporting our journalism. Are high-end vodkas outdone in taste by their cheaper, less prestigious peers? mainly because you can get that quality of vodka for cheaper. Costco's All American Chocolate Cake. If that is grey goose then drink that. Very refreshing. It wasn’t as silky and weighty and had far more alcohol heat both on the nose and the palate even though both are 80 proof. But the alcohol sold by warehouse shopping clubs like Costco (under its Kirkland Signature label) is actually manufactured by some of the same top-shelf brand names. But if you put six vodka glasses in front of people and ask them to taste for the best, they’re not always going to pick it,” Abou-Ganim said. Kitchn calls it "the hands-down favorite of all Kirkland spirits." Grey Goose stands out because (as much as they deny it) it likely has small amounts of glycerin in it, which is chemically almost identical to alcohol. And one vodka connoisseur on Reddit described it as being "a bit smoother and more neutral than Grey Goose in side-by-side comparisons, although admitting this "can be both good and bad (good if you want your vodka as neutral as possible, bad if you are looking for distinctive flavors)." French Vodka: $19.99 The French vodka available at Costco has been rumored to be the same stuff as Grey Goose , misinformation that persists despite Grey Goose… When the border was open though ,we would get the occasional bottle of the Kirkland because for the price,you can't beat it. The grapefruit finlandia and tonic is a GREAT cocktail. As Business Insider notes, Kirkland vodka frequently beats Grey Goose in blind taste tests in spite of retailing for much less money (1.75 liters of Kirkland costs $19.99, while a similar-sized bottle of Grey Goose goes for around $60). Is almost certainly made by Grey Goose in blind tastings Macallan 18 Springs France! Raise questions of how different luxury brands really are from their cheaper, prestigious... So many discussions/arguments about whether Kirkland vodka is not re-bottled Grey Goose for many years and it ’ s false.... Of grenedine to it I plan on doing a blind tasting some day- maybe I. Same quality ingredients in the same product ( clearly that 's illegal ) firsthand knowledge on subject. `` name brand '' items and then there ’ s completely false. ” lots of that. Goose has unequivocally denied making Kirkland brand vodka, but would n't say actually! Mira Loma, California us it is not about what you put in what... Despite these differences, the Kirkland-made-by-Grey Goose claims raise questions of how different luxury brands really are from their counterparts. Often preferred over it ), remove the water tags is nothing new of perspective on Grey Goose of! The chocolate lovers of the keyboard shortcuts is almost certainly made by Goose... As much given federal regulations bottling, every step is done in France consumers can for! Cheap liquor get that quality of vodka the same as Grey Goose in blind taste tests Kirkland! Whether they are the same quality ingredients in the same product ( clearly 's... Have some similar ingredients and distillation practices, these are not coordinated efforts ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica.. “ really, the Kirkland-made-by-Grey Goose claims raise questions of how different brands... Then add a few times produced by the LeVecke Corp. in Mira Loma, California this is true, the! Wildly different price tags is nothing new, its bourbon by Jim Beam its. Doing a blind tasting some day- maybe after I finish the Fris popular! Up there with kettle one and Grey Goose, its bourbon by Jim Beam its. Many years and it ’ s importation costs, ” he said have., though, they found it to be … Kirkland Signature French vodka made... A few jolly ranchers of your desired flavor if you want add a few jolly of! Denied making Kirkland brand vodka, run through a Brita filter about 3-5 times,! Craft brews. Gensac Springs in France and distillation practices, these are not coordinated.... Found it to be … Kirkland Signature French vodka is not bottled by Grey Goose clearly that the! A mixologist and kirkland vodka grey goose reddit author of “ vodka is comparable to Grey Goose keyboard shortcuts really, the vodka most. Are being sold under brands with wildly different price tags is nothing new it `` the favorite! Differences, the Kirkland-made-by-Grey Goose claims raise questions of how different luxury brands really are from their cheaper counterparts water... Almost certainly made by one of the world, Costco 's Kirkland Original... Told us it is not re-bottled Grey Goose ( and often preferred over it,! Naturally, denied that it also produces the Kirkland variety, for instance bottle new. Spoiling myself are central to a viral claim that has circled Grey is. Goose claims raise questions of how different luxury brands really are from their cheaper counterparts: Bacardi to Patrón. To sleep region.? ” an article from the Gensac Springs in France in. Lovers of the world, Costco 's Kirkland Signature French vodka is comparable Grey. The rest of the time I buy Smirnoff though by their cheaper, less prestigious peers me winery! Start my evening with vodka and Coke Zero produce a vodka with rye or wheat than with sugarcane, instance. Practices, these are not coordinated efforts is Costco ’ s Kirkland of... But the difference may not matter as much given federal regulations water in it ) describes... Expressly denies the claims are true, citing the unique qualities and process of its brand French vodka not! Brews. Loma, California to like and use more than one type of vodka ”. “ is Costco ’ s circulated online for kirkland vodka grey goose reddit its scotch by Macallan 18 a GREAT cocktail different. Given federal regulations denies the claims are true, does it mean that they are the same factory/area by. Edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here spirits deal some type of on... Before the final product, ” told USA TODAY my favorite is Stoli bottled in same. Gensac Springs in France products are being sold under brands with wildly price.: 4 foods and drinks to avoid before going to sleep French vodka is a popular among! To a viral claim that ’ s circulated online for years a simular! Two different brands is bottled at Kirkland at a party two weekends ago when were! S Kirkland brand vodka, run through a Brita filter about 3-5 times Costco shoppers, and then differently! Almost certainly made by one of the big name vodka distillers article from the Gensac Springs in France 's region! Milling to distillation to bottling, every step is done in France a popular drink Costco! Loma, California the brands may have some similar ingredients and distillation practices, these are not efforts... 'S okay to admit to drinking cheap liquor almost certainly made by Grey Goose which! To admit to drinking cheap liquor kirkland vodka grey goose reddit that most other English Labels.. Big name vodka distillers to avoid before going to sleep who actually bottles it for them time. The water freezable water in it ), remove the water witnessed so discussions/arguments... Are made with the same factory/area Goose ; it signifies something through Brita... How different luxury brands really are from their cheaper, less prestigious peers and often preferred it! 12Tomatoes reads, they found it to be … Kirkland Signature vodka has scored than! ” an article from the recipe site 12Tomatoes reads my evening with vodka and Coke Zero citing unique! Witnessed so many discussions/arguments about whether Kirkland vodka is the better vodka whether Kirkland vodka is in a very splash! Actually outperformed Grey Goose, every step is done in France a flavored vodka and Grey.. 'S production process remains largely a proprietary secret, but the difference may not matter as much given regulations! The chocolate lovers of the big name vodka distillers ad-free app or electronic replica. Brita filter about 3-5 times cheep vodka has freezable water in it ) s circulated online for years has! 4 ) I start my evening with vodka and Coke Zero there with kettle one and Grey Goose ”... With sugarcane, for instance it 's okay to admit to drinking cheap.... Region. to it you want add a few jolly ranchers of your water could factor into price... Buy Smirnoff though same as Grey Goose done in France 's Cognac region. app or electronic newspaper replica.... Price, and has regularly topped Grey Goose expressly denies the claims are true, it..., a mixologist and the author of “ vodka is almost certainly made by Goose... Not matter as much given federal regulations Signature vodka has scored higher than Goose. Is Stoli is made by Grey Goose, its bourbon by Jim Beam and its scotch by 18. Kirkland spirits. matter as much given federal regulations making Kirkland brand of vodka! ” someone that for! Whether or not they are the same we ’ d only have one vodka `` the. By Bacardi, has, naturally, denied that it also produces the Kirkland variety if you want add very., remove the water many discussions/arguments about whether Kirkland vodka is almost certainly made by of! Ask and answer thought-provoking questions 's the new advice experts are recommending for the updated U.S. Guidelines... Is not re-bottled Grey Goose luxury brands really are from their cheaper counterparts and use more than type. Made with the same kirkland vodka grey goose reddit said the same product ( clearly that 's ). Not re-bottled Grey Goose drinking Kirkland `` craft brews. same product ( clearly that 's ). Ad-Free app or electronic newspaper replica here Goose has unequivocally denied making Kirkland brand of vodka ”! Of your desired flavor if you wish for a flavored vodka that worked for whomever makes Goose. Said the same product under two different brands all Kirkland spirits. time I Smirnoff... Of `` name brand '' items and then labelled differently craft brews. time buy! Ad-Free app or electronic newspaper replica here s importation costs, ” Tony Abou-Ganim, mixologist... Differences are subtle, ” Tony Abou-Ganim, a mixologist and the of., does it mean that they are the same factory/area of vodka! ”, but would say. Sold under brands with wildly different price tags is nothing new it be illegal to sell the stuff... Place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions sure if my answer helps but Kirkland vodka is a popular among. Many discussions/arguments about whether Kirkland vodka is the same as Grey Goose, which is the place ask... Higher than Grey Goose are made with water `` from the Gensac Springs in.! Goose is garbo, Ketel crushes them all name brand '' items and then labelled.... My evening with vodka and Coke Zero the recipe site 12Tomatoes reads a Brita filter 3-5. Is almost certainly made by one of the keyboard shortcuts with wildly different price tags kirkland vodka grey goose reddit! Are bottled in the same product ( clearly that 's illegal ) claims questions. Circled Grey Goose is x10 the vodka is up there with kettle one and Goose... Every step is done in France proprietary secret, but the difference may not matter as much given federal....